October 2026 | By Amy Walton
Feedback is a natural part of the composition classroom– opportunities for peer feedback, instructor feedback, and student feedback in class can be built in regularly throughout the semester. Midterm is a natural time for students and instructors to reflect on what is working well in class and what could be improved.
Our course shells provide several feedback opportunities, like rubrics/comment boxes in Canvas and the Plus/Delta course survey. However, the feedback process shouldn’t end when you enter it in Canvas. Teachers and students alike benefit from taking time to review, reflect on, and follow up on others’ comments.
In this “Up Next,” I’ll give some strategies for what to do after the feedback comes in or goes out.
Plus/Delta
The Plus/Delta tool in our Canvas shells (explained here by CELT), is set to be completed at the end of the second major unit of our courses. Beyond just assigning it to your students, the tool can provide the opportunity to work with your students on how to write specific, constructive feedback that a) helps them in peer review and b) makes for more effective comments on the end-of-semester Student Ratings of Teaching. CELT provides helpful guidance for framing feedback here.
As CELT notes, the feedback loop is not closed with the completion of the survey. Instead, be sure to read the student responses and report out on themes, advice, and your reflection on the semester.
You can access your student feedback by creating a “student analysis” report through “Survey Statistics.”

Then, plan for a follow-up with your students. This could be a video announcement in an online course or a discussion in a face-to-face class. I like to create two slides: “notes for students” and “notes for the teacher,” and share my takeaways from the responses.

Helpful trends to note in your follow-up discussion with students:
- What they feel is working best
- What they feel isn’t working
- What student habits are helping their learning
- What habits they want to change in the second half of the semester
- What you as a teacher can (and plan to) change in response to the feedback
- What you as a teacher can’t change (for example, “I can’t change the textbook, but here are some ways that students are using it in a helpful way…”)
This doesn’t have to be the only opportunity for students to share what is and isn’t working for them. Some instructors invite feedback at the end of a class, week, or unit to inform what to tackle next.
Major Assignment Feedback
Similarly, students will get the most out of the feedback you give them on major assignments if you facilitate engagement with your comments. The following are considerations and ideas for working this into your class.
Accessibility
Make sure that students know where to find your feedback. For online courses, you can post a video in the student view to show how to see comments, rubrics, and the annotated drafts. In class, you can walk students through this process.
Engagement
Give students a task to do that requires them to interact with your feedback. Here are some ideas for what you can do after students have read your feedback.
- Write a response to your feedback. What is most helpful? What do they need to work on next?
- Use the feedback to plan revisions for their next assignment.
- Review the feedback before conferences and ask questions.
- In preparation for the Portfolio assignment, go back and observe trends in strengths and weaknesses noted in the rubrics and comments.
Making the feedback loop a priority throughout the course helps demystify the process and strengthen respect and communication in the classroom community. Consider how you might build off of a feedback opportunity that already exists in your classroom!